Words by Emma Paidra, Uncloseted Media

On a Sunday evening in Midtown Manhattan, a group of around 20 lesbians met at The Grisly Pear to mix, mingle and maybe spark a romantic connection. 

In addition to being gay, these women shared another key similarity. 

Attendees of this meet-up – which was organised by the Log Cabin Republicans (LCR), America’s oldest LGBTQIA+ organisation for conservatives – represent the small minority of gay Republican women. 

While many people may find a conservative lesbian to be counterintuitive, roughly 13 per cent of LGBTQIA+ voters cast their ballot for Trump in the 2024 Presidential election. 

As the evening kicked off, Rachel Herman, a 40-year-old LCR New York board member, welcomed attendees. With an LCR pin fastened to her grey blazer, she sat on a barstool near the pub’s entrance, introducing herself as people trickled in. For Herman, the need to get involved in LGBTQIA+ Republican circles came after she was kicked out of her gay billiards league when her team found out she was conservative.